Monday, February 13, 2012

NAIROBI SECURITIES EXCHANGE CHAIRMAN’S 2011 YEAR REVIEW NAIROBI SECURITIES EXCHANGE CHAIRMAN’S 2011 YEAR REVIEW

NAIROBI SECURITIES EXCHANGE
CHAIRMAN’S 2011 YEAR REVIEW
On behalf of the Board of the Nairobi Securities Exchange (NSE), I would like to highlight the reasons why we remain optimistic that the market will rebound in the medium term despite the economic turbulence experienced last year. It is true that the domestic and global financial markets are experiencing a general downturn caused by the high international oil prices, fluctuations in the exchange rate, inadequate rainfall and rising global food prices. Here in Kenya the inflation hit a high of 19.72% in November 2011 and the real GDP growth slowed to an estimated 3.6% from a projected figure of 5.3%.
REVIEW OF MARKET PERFORMANCE IN 2011
The Capital Markets registered a decline in performance in 2011 in comparison to 2010 characterized by decreased activity in the secondary markets. Reduced economic growth resulted to lower turnovers in the equity market caused by; the rising inflation in the second half of the year, higher and volatile interest rates, depreciation (and volatility) of the shilling against major currencies and Kenya’s incursion in Somalia. We also witnessed a shift of investors from equities to fixed deposits, treasury bills and bonds which are considered lower risk assets. The NSE 20 Share Index reported a 27.7% decline, closing at 3205.02 points at the end of 2011, down from 4,433 points reported at the end of December 2010. The All Share
Index (NASI) reported a 30.6% decline closing at 68.03 points at the end of 2011 down from 98 points at the end of December 2010
POSITIVE MACROECONOMIC OUTLOOK
We however maintain a positive outlook for the medium term. According to the World
Bank, the real GDP growth is expected to rebound to 5.9% in 2012, as the economy recovers from the drought in 2011. The World Bank forecasts that growth will be in the 5-5.6% range in 2013-16. After surging to a high of 19.72% in 2011, inflation is forecast to retreat to 6.7% in 2012 and to remain in the 5-6% range in 2013-16, helped by prudent monetary policies and more stable global commodity prices. Additionally, after rising to 8.1% of GDP in 2011, underpinned by costlier oil, the current account deficit is expected to narrow gradually, helped by steady growth in earnings from exports, tourism and remittances.
STRUCTURAL REFORMS
On January 31 2011, the Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IM F) approved a three-year arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility for Kenya in an amount equivalent to SDR 325.68 million (about US$508.7 million). The program aims to protect Kenya’s external position, while allowing a gradual fiscal adjustment. In December 2011, following the completion of the second review of Kenya’s economic performance the IMF Board approved an augmentation of access equal to 60 percent of quota, leading to a total access of 180 percent of quota, an amount equivalent to SDR 488.52 million (about US$760.63 million). The government further aims to quicken the pace of structural reforms in 2011-12, including deregulation and trade liberalization (especially within the EAC). It also plans to dispose of full or partial stakes in some state enterprises in a range of sectors, either by selling shares to strategic partners or through flotations on the Nairobi Securities Exchange. In 2011, we witnessed the beginning of an overhaul of company law, insolvency law and capital markets regulations. Although the 2012 elections may distract policymakers, the elections are unlikely to trigger any major policy shifts, as all key parties support a free market system which supports the Economic pillar of Kenya’s Vision 2030. Foreign policy will continue to be driven by economic interests, including the maintenance of close relations with key donors and the advance of regional integration, especially within the East African Community (EAC).
In the medium term, the expectations about Kenya’s economic projections continue to be optimistic, with economic recovery projected to accelerate largely due to improved performance of key sectors and domestic demand. Indeed, in anticipation of an improved economic environment going forward, and in order to improve our reach, we continue to innovate and benchmark against best practices.
THE NSE MILESTONES
As part of our Vision “To be a leading securities exchange in Africa, with a global reach.”, last year saw us accomplishing the following major milestones;
1. NAME CHANGE
The Nairobi Stock Exchange changed her name to the Nairobi Securities Exchange Limited. It reflects the fact that besides stocks, the Nairobi Securities Exchange (NSE) offers a platform for the issuance and trading of debt securities. The NSE is also growing its portfolio of information products and services. This name change is in line with the 2010 – 2014 strategic plan of the Nairobi Securities Exchange to evolve into a full service securities exchange which supports trading, clearing and settlement of equities, debt, derivatives and other associated instruments.
2. RE-REGISTRATION OF THE COMPANY
The Nairobi Stock Exchange converted from a company limited by guarantee to a company limited by shareholding; a function that was also marked by the re-registration from the Nairobi Stock Exchange to the Nairobi Securities Exchange Limited.
3. REDUCTION OF THE SETTLEMENT CYCLE
The equity settlement cycle moved from the previous T+4 settlement cycle to the T+3 settlement cycle. This market milestone is in line with international best practice.
Trading in debt securities was already on a T+3 settlement cycle. We expect that the efficiency gains from this shorter settlement cycle will improve liquidity in the market for listed equity securities thus making our market more attractive to domestic and foreign investors.
4. NSE BROKER BACK OFFICE SYSTEM
The Broker Back Office (BBO) went live and is now undergoing the test phase to optimize system customization. The BBO system automates the entire process of transacting in shares with minimal manual intervention and is interfaced with the Automated Trading System (ATS) and Central Depository System (CDS). This system will reduce the risk of trading in securities listed on the NSE, boost investor confidence and facilitate greater access by enabling internet trading. The Broker Back Office will improve the integrity of the Exchange trading systems and facilitate greater access to our securities market.
5. COMPANY RECLASSIFICATION
We reclassified the industry sectors under which our listed companies are placed.
Equities are now classified under ten (10) industry sectors. Debt securities including preference shares are classified under three (3) categories. This reclassification brings us closer to international best practise and will enable domestic and international investors to more easily compare company and sector performance. We are convinced that the reclassification will provide a more accurate reflection of the diversity of the companies listed at the NSE and by extension reflect the increasing diversification of our economy.
6. FTSE NSE KENYA INDEX SERIES
On November 8, 2011 we successfully launched the FTSE NSE Kenya 15 and FTSE NSE Kenya 25 Indices. The launch of the indices is the result of an extensive market consultation process with local asset owners and fund managers and reflects the growing interest in new domestic investment and diversification opportunities in the East African region. Designed to enhance and capture the depth of information available on the Kenyan market, the indices are also suitable as the foundation for ETFs and other index-linked products which can also be utilized by global investors wishing to access this frontier market. These indices are running concurrently with the NSE 20 Share and NSE All Share indices. The branded indices give the NSE the opportunity to use FTSE’s expertise to design, manage and distribute branded indices and index related products, domestically and internationally. Overall, the indices should improve capital flows into the domestic market and enhance liquidity and market capitalization.
7. NEW LISTINGS
2011 was a year of listings at the NSE. We welcomed three (3) new companies and saw the reinstatement of one. CFC Insurance Holdings listed on the Main Investment Market segment (MIMS) under the Insurance subsector joining three (3) other insurance companies. Transcentury Ltd listed by way of introduction joining seven (7) other companies listed on the Alternative Investment Market Segment (AIMS), British American Investments Company Ltd. (Britak) was the third company to list joining four (4) other insurance companies on the Main Investment Market Segment (MIMS). In 2011, we witnessed the re-listing of Uchumi Supermarkets Ltd on the Main Investment Market after a five (5) year suspension from trading. On the Debt market, we also witnessed the listing of the first Tranche of the Shelter Afrique Kshs 3 Billion Medium Term Note (MTN) Issue. This illustrates the confidence our corporates have placed in our market’s ability to meet their ongoing needs.
The Board and Management will continue to support innovations that will aid in the growth of the market. In 2012, we will prioritize the following initiatives:-
2012 OUTLOOK
1. TREASURY BOND INDEX
Together with FTSE International, we are working on introducing a Treasury Bond Index, which we believe will enable our investors to accurately measure the performance of their bond portfolios.
2. GROWTH ENTERPRISE MARKET SEGMENT (GEMS)
We are in the process of setting up the Growth Enterprise Market Segment (GEMS), a Mid Cap Market Segment. This market segment will facilitate the listing of Small and Medium Sized Enterprises (SMEs). The establishment of the Mid Cap market segment is not only expected to diversify the avenues of long term capital for SMEs, but also raise the level of savings and investments within the capital markets through additional listings. The introduction of the Mid Cap Market is in line with the Government focus on the SME sector as one of the key drivers of Vision 2030, destined to play an effective role as an engine for economic growth, poverty eradication, and employment creation. The Board of the Capital Markets Authority approved the rules and regulations for GEMS. The regulations will now be forwarded to the Minister for Finance for gazettement and the market is expected to be operational in the second half of 2012.
3. NEW LISTINGS
This year, we anticipate an estimated five (5) companies will be coming to the market to raise capital. When a Company is listed, it makes a statement of its commitment to transparency and good corporate governance. The shareholders have an opportunity to scrutinize and question the Board and Management on the performance of the company. Through its share price, the company will also get a market viewpoint on its performance. We shall continue to support such transactions that provide value to the shareholders, employees and our economy.
4. DEMUTUALIZATION
February 3, 2012 marked the end of a five (5) months legal process after Justice Cecilia Githua ruled in favour of the NSE in a matter against Francis Thuo & Partners that had halted the demutualization process. In her ruling, she held that the Nairobi Securities Exchange is a Limited Liability Company and that therefore the NSE is not amenable to judicial review. I am happy to note that this ruling marks a significant step towards the completion of the Demutualization process. The NSE remains committed to settling any outstanding issues with Francis Thuo & Partners Ltd. As I have repeatedly stated, demutualization of the NSE is a statement of our commitment to transparency and good corporate governance and that this improved governance is critical in attracting investors and increasing opportunities to raise debt and equity through the capital markets, which resonates with the NSE’s vision, To be the leading securities exchange in Africa with a global reach.
APPRECIATION
On behalf of the Board of the Directors of the NSE, I wish to express our unreserved appreciation to all investors– domestic and foreign, our listed companies and our market intermediaries for their continued support. I wish to appreciate the Government of Kenya for showing commitment to the capital markets, and to the President, His Excellency Honorable Mwai Kibaki for honoring us with his distinguished presence twice in 2011 during our listing ceremonies. Indeed, I wish to reiterate that the NSE remains committed to facilitating the Government’s efforts to tap private capital to support investment in Vision 2030 projects.
EDDY NJOROGE
CHAIRMAN

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

An Instructive Quote

« If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. If you know yourself but not the enemy, for every victory gained you will also suffer a defeat. If you know neither the enemy nor yourself, you will succumb in every battle. »
Sun Tzu

Friday, February 3, 2012

What if leadership wasn't a promotion?

Josh Bersin recently wrote a stellar post titled "The End of a Job as We Know It." One of the jobs that might end is the one called "boss."
For me, a "boss" is someone responsible for the performance of a group. There is plenty of leadership without position going on every day, all over the world, but I write this blog specifically for the men and women who are organizationally responsible for group performance. That requires position as well as influence.
Well, if Josh Bersin is right, many of those classic boss positions may become a thing of the past. He's not alone in that prediction. I recently wrote "You can eliminate the bosses, but," sparked by one of Harold Jarche's posts. Many others have said similar things. The powerful part of Bersin's post, for me, was the way he combined two insights. Here's one of them.
"What this all means is that in today's high performing companies, people now take on 'roles' not 'jobs.' They are responsible for 'tasks' and 'projects' and not simply 'functions.'"
That's pretty straightforward. I've heard it from Susan Finerty in our conversations over the last year or so. Susan thinks that every organization is becoming a matrix organization, whether it's officially called that or not. That means multiple relationships and reporting points, and, often, less hierarchy. Now here's the other Bersin insight.
"And leadership, by the way, is just a 'role' like any other - with its own particular set of skills."
That resonates with me because I think that leadership is a kind of work. Some people are suited for it, want to do it, and will do it well. Others will not.
Moving from individual contributor to a leadership role is more like a career change than a promotion. It's like changing from engineering to architecture. Leadership work is important work, but it's not more exalted work.
If we see leadership as a role, not a promotion or a position in the hierarchy, lots of things become possible. People can lead in situations where their strengths leverage the strengths of others and their weaknesses are irrelevant. Groups and teams can select a leader, instead of always having the leader selected from above. People can try out the role and decide if they like it and, if they don't, they can never do it again, with no stigma or career penalty.
Will things turn out this way? We can't ever be sure of the details of how big changes will end up. Because the change looks so clear, it's tempting to think it will happen quickly. Probably not. If history is a good guide, this kind of change will take a generation cycle or two to become the norm, so probably twenty to forty years.
Does all this make sense to you? How do you imagine that things will change?
Wally's Working Supervisor's Support Kit is a collection of information and tools to help working supervisors do a better job. It's based on what Wally's learned in over twenty years of supervisory skills training. Click here to check it out.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Measuring the Efficacy of the World's Managers

Published:
January 30, 2012
Author:
Carmen Nobel


Firms in the United States, Japan, and Germany tend to be managed especially well, while firms in Brazil, China, and India tend to be managed poorly.
Those are among the initial findings of the World Management Survey (WMS), a huge international research initiative to measure differences in organizational management practices all over the world.
The project was borne of a widely perceived gap in economic research. In business academia, there is an optimistic tendency to assume that managers generally make decisions in the best interest of their firms' performance. Reality is more frustrating. The fact is, some companies are managed beautifully, others dismally.
"During the interview she got a marriage proposal. The manager wanted her to marry his son."
"It's very tough to believe that there are such wide differences in management out there," says Raffaella Sadun, an assistant professor at Harvard Business School who coleads the WMS with Nicholas Bloom of Stanford University and John Van Reenen of the London School of Economics. "If you really want to be convincing, it's important to have large-scale statistical evidence," she adds.
To that end, over the past seven years, large teams of affiliated WMS analysts have interviewed managers at some 10,000 organizations in 20 countries, setting out to determine how and why management practices differ vastly in style and quality.

Best practices

The researchers used an evaluation tool designed by a leading consultancy firm that broadly rated management practices in three areas: monitoring—how well managers keep track of what's happening in a firm and make good use of that information;targets—how well organizations set appropriate goals and outcomes, and whether they take action if the two are inconsistent; and incentives—whether organizations promoted and rewarded employees based on performance and tried to keep the best performers from quitting.
To collect the data, the researchers hired teams of MBA students who could interview managers in their respective native languages. The respondents chosen for the survey included primarily middle managers in manufacturing plants, although over time the data collection was extended to other industries, such as retail, schools, and hospitals. The approach was to interview those who were high enough on the corporate totem pole to have a good overview of management practices, but low enough that they were familiar with day-to-day operations. The researchers also chose to target primarily small and medium-sized firms, employing between 100 and 5,000 workers, to maximize the chances that the interview would capture salient features of the whole organization, as opposed to the characteristics of single plants.
Rather than limiting the responses with multiple choice or yes/no questions, the interviewers kept the questions open-ended to get a complete picture of the actual practices adopted in the organization. This method was also useful to build an effective bond between the interviewer and the manager, which sometimes led to answers that were both thoughtful and entertaining. (Responding to a question about staff retention, for instance, one manager said, "I spend most of my time walking around cuddling and encouraging people. My staff tells me that I give great hugs.")
"We had very interesting experiences," Sadun recalls. "Once, a student was interviewing a manager, and during the interview she got a marriage proposal. The manager wanted her to marry his son."

Key findings

The researchers have summarized the initial results of the study in a new working paper, Management Practices across Firms and Countries,—also coauthored by Christos Genakos of the Athens University of Economics and Business—and have posted a comprehensive collection of the survey data on theWorld Management Survey website. The WMS site also features individual policy reports for manufacturing, education, health-care, and retail organizations, providing a management benchmark for executives in any of those fields.
On average, based on the evaluation tool, the research showed that firms in the United States, Japan, and Germany tend to be the best-managed in the world, while firms in Brazil, China, and India scored poorly.
"You have a lot of companies where the transmission of leadership is based on criteria completely unrelated to your ability to lead."
Of the 20 countries in the survey, the United States received the highest overall management scores in retail, health care, and manufacturing. But US schools scored comparatively lower, coming in fourth behind the United Kingdom, Sweden, and Canada.
"US schools in particular tend to be particularly poor at incentives management—that is, promoting and rewarding high-performing teachers, and retraining and/or firing badly performing teachers," the paper states.
In the United States, India, and China, managerial use of incentives are much more common than the use of monitoring and target-setting, especially in the manufacturing field. In Japan, Sweden, and Germany, monitoring and target-setting far exceed the use of incentives.
But the differences surpassed international boundaries. "There is so much dispersion, even within the same industries and same countries," Sadun says, explaining that the researchers managed to discover certain ownership patterns that help to explain the dispersion.
For instance, government-owned organizations tend to receive low management scores across all the sectors and countries in the study. "They are particularly weak at incentives," the paper explains. "Promotion is more likely to be based on tenure (rather than performance), and persistent low-performers are much less likely to be retrained or moved."
Family-owned businesses scored even lower—particularly those run by a firstborn son who inherited the role of CEO. Family-owned businesses that employed a non-related CEO scored much higher. "The finding there is not so much that family ownership per se is associated with lower scores, but rather family ownership when the selection of the CEO is not meritocratic," Sadun says. "Especially in Europe, you have a lot of companies where the transmission of leadership is based on criteria completely unrelated to your ability to lead."
Also receiving low management scores across the board: organizations at which the company founder was also the CEO. "We systematically find that founders have lower levels of scores," Sadun says. "One possible explanation is that founders are great at the start-up phase because they have the vision and the motivation. But as the firm grows, to do the ongoing management on a daily basis requires a different set of skills."
Market competition appears to be good for management. The research showed that a company's overall management score wass directly related to how many competitors a firm faces—the higher number of reported competitors, the higher the management score. And multinational firms scored higher than their domestic counterparts across all the industries and countries in the survey.
Education makes a difference, too. The data showed that the greater the percentage of employees with a college degree in manufacturing and retail firms, the greater the management scores. In hospitals, a greater management score correlated with the percentage of managers who also had clinical experience.

Next steps

With the initial data tracked and scored, the researchers are now working with the US Census Bureau to build an even larger set of management data. Last spring they conducted a survey of more than 48,000 US companies, using the questions and the evaluation tool from the initial WMS survey. The Census Bureau already keeps general track of firms' financial performance in the United States. The WMS team plans to match the management survey data against the financial performance data in order to investigate the link between management quality and the bottom line across an even larger number of organizations.
The researchers have also started to work on management experiments, modeled on the randomized control trials adopted in the medical field. This experimental approach is much more costly and labor- intensive than the survey methodology, Sadun says, but it allows them to identify with much greater precision the causal link between management and performance.
"We want to get at the causality between management and performance," she says. "And to do that, you have to go beyond surveys and start running experiments with firms. That's the most challenging but also the most interesting part of where this research is going." http://hbswk.hbs.edu/images/site/tack-wk.gif

About the author

Carmen Nobel is senior editor of Harvard Business School Working Knowledge

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

What are your children reading?

WEDNESDAY, 01 FEBRUARY 2012 10:15 BY CAROLE KIAMAH
I once attended a class on developing curriculum. The teacher made an interesting comment that learning takes place via connections. We all have a frame of reference to which we attach any new data coming in through our senses. That meant that the more exposed a person is, the more likely they were to do well in school because they had a greater reference from where to draw from. The news was mind boggling for me, with my children still fairly young it meant that I could increase their capacity to learn by exposing them to more things that could increase their frame of reference.
I began to be quite intentional in exposing them to as much information as they could take in the different spheres of their learning. For geography, we began travelling and where we could not go physically, we travelled through the wonderful world of books. We visited various parts of the country where they learnt about different people, groups and cultures. They learnt about the density of water when we visited Mombasa and Lake Bogoria, saw the hot springs, the different animals in the parks and the famous pink flamingoes in Lake Nakuru and became exposed to the various facets of our country and people.
Helping them with their English was a little trickier. I tried to make them discover the beautiful world of books as opposed to watching it through a movie. It was not an easy buy, both wondered, why read a 20-page rendition of Aladdin when you can always watch a movie? I tried to make them see that a movie was someone else’s interpretation of a good story and that by reading the book, they could create their own interpretation. Let us say, it is an ongoing struggle.
Some of the books had no cultural relevance, what was with the short plump man with a long beard who went down people’s chimneys and gave them toys at Christmas? What happened to the poor child in Africa who had neither chimney nor snow for the sleigh? And what are fairies anyway? I think little sparkly ladies who brandish sticks and have wings are spooky and so are little short ugly men with big hats (goblins). A good witch, a cow that jumps over the moon, and a moon made out of cheese? What exactly are we teaching our children? And what is this entire rave about witches and wizards anyway. Why would I want TJ or Toriah’s hero to be a little boy who is studying to be a wizard, or a grown man who spends his day in a pajama outfit and a mask climbing walls like a spider?
One of my favourite stories when I was young was the little matchstick girl, a story of a little poor girl who had nothing to eat and kept looking at the sumptuous feasts in other people’s homes by peeping through the windows. She finally starves to death and is carried off to heaven. I don’t know why I liked it but when I read it to the boys they made me see it in a whole new perspective. “But why did they not invite her to their homes?” Easy enough “They did not see her”. “Okay, but why did she not just knock and say she needed some food?” Good point. I wonder why the author did not think of it. Come to think of it, what exactly was the moral of the story?
The more I look at what is available for children to read the more I wonder what happened to some of the good old books that were available when we were younger. The How stories; the Where stories; and the When stories. What happened to legends like Luanda Magere and Mzee Kiundu (remember the greedy dude who missed out on food by trying to be in two places at the same time?). What happened to the crafty tortoise that won the race or the greedy hyena? Those were great books that were relevant to us and our culture. Suffice to say, Grace Odhiambo and others like her are needed back to their computers.
Our children are in dire need for more of Africa. They need to know about the hare and the tortoise. They need to learn our own folk lores. I must admit that I loved the books that Kenya Institute of Education released years back, comics with our own traditional stories. I cannot wait to introduce my children to Wangu wa Makeri (the ultra feminist), Luanda Magere (our equivalent of Incredible hulk) and Ole-Kuiyot. Perhaps in the quest for entertainment they will also learn a little more of this wonderful continent and its rich culture.

Investing in Renewable Energy is Good for the United States and the World

Statement of United Nations Foundation President Timothy E. Wirth on President Obama’s State of the Union Address 
Washington, D.C. (January 25, 2012) – In his State of the Union address, President Barack Obama highlighted the importance of increased investment in renewable energy and greater energy efficiency. Prioritizing sustainable energy will position the United States and its partners for a stronger economic future, and will help advance global sustainable energy goals.


“United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon outlined the global vision earlier this month in a New York Times Op-Ed on his Sustainable Energy for All initiative. He set his sights on 2030, challenging governments, corporations, and people everywhere to create ‘a world with universal energy access coupled with significantly improved rates of energy efficiency and a doubling of renewable energy in our mix of fuel source.’ In order to accomplish this vision, Ban wrote, ‘We need to raise sustainable energy to the top of the global agenda and focus our attention, ingenuity, resources, and investments to make it a reality.’


President Obama’s remarks last night in his address to the nation once again demonstrated the close alignment of U.S. policy goals and the UN’s leadership in the international community. That’s why I am proud to serve as a member of the UN Secretary-General’s High­-level Group on Sustainable Energy for All. This topic will be a major focus of the Rio+20 summit in June – the UN Conference on Sustainable Development – and today the Secretary-General reiterated his commitment to sustainable development as the top priority of his second five-year term, which began this month. Both the President and Secretary-General remind us that now is the time to take on the issue of sustainable energy, with policies and investments that build a better, more secure future for everyone.”

Study suggests disarmingly simple way to better job ethics: slow down

Media contact: Benjamin Haimowitz, (212) 233-6170, HHaimowitz@aol.com
When the FBI made front-page headlines recently with the arrest of a coterie of  financial traders and analysts charged with tens of millions dollars worth of securities fraud, it was only the most recent of dozens of similar cases over the past two years. Yet, such big-time rip-offs, spectacular though they are, represent only a tiny sliver of the nation's total business-related cheating, according to the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, which estimates that U.S. business lost close to a trillion dollars from employee fraud in one recent year.

Is such a massive amount of cheating indicative of  a work force that is hopelessly corrupt? Research in the new issue of the Academy of Management Journal suggests not. It finds that, confronted with clear choices between right and wrong, people are more than five times more likely to do the right thing when they have some time to think about the matter than they are when they have to make a snap decision.

"Having time to think things over may not make much difference in big-time financial swindles, but our findings suggest that it would make a considerable difference in innumerable instances of lying and fraud that happen every day in the business world," comments J. Keith Murnighan of the Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University, who carried out the new research with Brian Gunia of Johns Hopkins University, Long Wang of City University of Hong Kong, and Li Huang and Jiunwen Wang of Northwestern.

In explanation, Prof. Murnighan adds: "Immediate, automatic moral intuitions tend to be selfish, given that self-interest is a basic, instinctual response to external stimuli. In contrast, conscious, deliberative thought adds social concerns, setting off a battle within the individual that pits the strength of self-interested intuitive desires against the constraints established by social learning."
 
The study also finds that even a modest nudge on behalf of morality can carry the day in such battles, with ethical urgings four times more likely to engender good deeds than advice on behalf of self-interest will.

In sum, as the study puts it, "Organizations with a 'fast pulse' or tendency to reward quick decision-making may suffer ethical penalties by discouraging contemplation and conversation... At a minimum, our results suggest that individual, organizational actors facing right-wrong decisions should take the time to think or to consult an ethical colleague."

The findings emerge from experiments involving 146 college undergraduates who were confronted with a moral dilemma that the researchers manipulated in several different ways. Seated at computer terminals, participants were told that $15 would be divided between them and another student (who, unbeknownst to the subjects actually did not exist) according to one of two options. In Option A, the participant would received $10 and the other student $5; in Option B, the participant would receive $5 and the other student $10. The imaginary other student would choose one option or the other, and it was up to the participant to send beforehand one of two messages of advice. A truthful message would be "Option B earns you more than Option A"; a lie would be "Option A earns you more than Option B."

In one variation, the "immediate-choice condition," participants received instructions and proceeded directly to a screen that asked them to send the message within 30 seconds. In the "contemplation condition," subjects first encountered a screen that remained visible for three minutes and that asked the subject to "please think very carefully about which message to send."

The difference between the two groups was dramatic: 26 of 30 subjects in the contemplation condition (87%) told the truth even though it resulted in their receiving less money than their anonymous counterparts. This compared to 19 of 34 (56%) of the subjects who were asked to make an immediate choice.

In a second experiment, subjects were confronted with the same two options, but this time, before making a decision, they received one of three brief emails from a third party (again fictional) who was supposedly facing the same dilemma. One message "guess[ed] that most people would b honest on this kinda situation;" a second couldn't "help thinking that most other people would try to gain the most money"; a third offered no particular advice, "guessing most people would have a hard time deciding what to do in this kinda situation."

Again the results presented a stark contrast: 20 of 25 subjects who received the ethical email (80%) told the truth, in contrast to 14 of 28 (50%) who were urged to attend to their self-interest and 20 of 29 (69%) who were not given any particular advice.

While such results suggest the benefits that derive from an ethical workplace milieu, the professors express concern about the "potent effects" of the superficial advice proffered in the experiments. In the words of the study, "Given the current ubiquity of email and text messaging, these findings are troubling. More generally they suggest that right-wrong decisions can put people on the fence, straddling ethical action and temptation, and that even minimal influence processes can have big effects...Whether [the advice] led them toward or away from ethicality, the fact that people were influenced at all by such minimal conversations is troubling, as it suggests that people routinely depend on others, even unknown others, to direct their moral choices."  

In conclusion, the study urges organizations to "consciously design moral decision-making processes, integrating them into training and enforcing them institutionally via policies, rewards, and sanctions. Policies mandating a 'cooling-off period' or multiple levels of approval for consequential decisions, for example, might provide institutional analogs for contemplation, and ethics hotlines might act as institutional conversations. Opportunities for instituting and improving these kinds of procedures abound."

Adds Prof. Murnighan: "Executives know what types of decisions raise moral red flags in their companies. If people make these decisions electronically, their computers might be programmed to require contemplation time before decisions are finalized -- and even to fill this time with reminders of the firm's ethical values. Managers already employ similar technology, though usually for non-moral purposes. Hopefully, they will assign enough priority to ethics to adapt existing tools for the purpose of encouraging what's right."

The new study, entitled "Contemplation and Conversation: Subtle Influences on Moral Decision-Making" is in the February/March issue of the The Academy of Management Journal.  This peer-reviewed publication is published every other month by the Academy, which, with about 18,000 members in 103 countries, is the largest organization in the world devoted to management research and teaching. The Academy's other publications are theThe Academy of Management Review, The Academy of Management Perspectives and Academy of Management Learning and Education
Media Coverage:
hbr.com. Extra thinking time leads to ethical decisions. (Tuesday, January 31, 2012)